If your heater is not working on the first cold night, start with four quick checks: make sure the thermostat is set to HEAT and above room temperature, check its batteries, check the breaker for your heating system, and look at the air filter. If you have a heat pump, check whether it is set to emergency heat. If none of that brings the heat back, it is time for a pro.
Why does the heat act up on the first cold night?
In Northeast Florida, your heat sits unused for most of the year. Then a cold front rolls through, you flip the thermostat over to heat, and you find out whether everything still works.
That first night usually comes in November. According to NWS Jacksonville climate records, the average November low in the Jacksonville area is about 51 degrees, based on the 1991 to 2020 climate normals. So if your heater is not working this month, you are not alone. A lot of St. Augustine homeowners are flipping the switch for the first time at the same moment you are.
The good news: a lot of first-night problems come down to a setting, a dead battery or a dirty filter. You can check all of those yourself in a few minutes, safely, without opening up any equipment.
Start here: 4 simple checks before you call
Work through these in order. None of them require tools, and none of them involve opening the unit or touching wiring.
1. Check the thermostat
- Make sure the mode is set to HEAT, not COOL or OFF. After a long cooling season, it is easy to forget it is still on cool.
- Set the temperature a few degrees above the current room temperature so the system has a reason to turn on.
- If the screen is blank or dim, put in fresh batteries.
2. Check the breaker
Go to your electrical panel and look for a breaker labeled for the air handler, furnace or heat pump. If one is tripped, flip it fully off and then back on. If it trips again, leave it off and call for service. A breaker that keeps tripping is a sign something needs a professional, so do not keep resetting it.
3. Check the air filter
A clogged filter chokes airflow, so your system works harder and less warm air reaches your rooms. Pull the filter and hold it up to the light. If you cannot see through it, replace it. In our climate, we recommend checking and changing standard 1-inch filters monthly.
4. Check the emergency heat setting (heat pumps)
If you have a heat pump, many heat pump thermostats have an EM HEAT or Emergency Heat setting. If it was switched on by accident, the outdoor unit may not run at all. If your heat pump stopped heating completely, emergency heat can keep the house warm until help arrives, but it costs more to run. Our guide to emergency heat vs. aux heat explains when to use it and what it costs.
While you are at the thermostat, also make sure the supply vents in your rooms are open and not blocked by furniture or rugs.
Is that normal? A few first-night surprises
A dusty, burning smell when the heat first comes on
A light, dusty smell the first time the heat runs is common. Dust settles on the heating parts over the long off-season and burns off when they warm up. If the smell is strong, smells like plastic or wires, or will not go away, turn the system off and call. Our post on why your heater smells like burning walks through the difference.
The heat pump is blowing cool air
If the air from your heat pump feels cool instead of warm, see heat pump blowing cold air when it’s cold outside for what is normal and what is not.
Frost or steam on the outdoor unit
On a cold, damp night, a little frost on the outdoor unit or a cloud of steam during a defrost cycle can be normal. A unit that stays frozen solid is not. Here is how to tell normal defrost from a real freeze-up.
When to stop and call a pro
Stop troubleshooting and call if:
- The breaker trips again after you reset it once.
- You smell burning plastic or wiring, or the smell will not go away.
- The system will not turn on even with the thermostat on HEAT, fresh batteries and a clean filter.
- The outdoor unit stays covered in ice.
- You hear new banging, grinding or squealing.
Anything past the four checks above is a job for a licensed technician. Electrical parts, controls and safety switches are where we troubleshoot, and that is not something to take apart yourself.
How Wright Brothers handles heating repair in St. Augustine
When you call us for heating repair in St. Augustine, here is what happens:
- We schedule you fast, often the same day. We are open 24 hours, Monday through Saturday.
- A licensed tech finds the real problem, not just the symptom.
- You get a clear, flat-rate price before any work starts. You decide. No pressure, and we will never sell you a repair you do not need.
- We fix it and test it to make sure your system is running right before we leave.
New customers get $50 off your first service.
Frequently asked questions
How often should I change my air filter?
In Florida’s climate, we recommend checking and changing standard 1-inch filters monthly, especially during peak cooling season, to ensure proper airflow and healthy indoor air quality.
Why is my heating bill high when I barely use my heat?
A high bill often points to an underlying issue with your heat pump or furnace efficiency. It could be dirty coils, leaky ductwork, or a failing component. A tune-up can quickly diagnose the problem.
Do you service my area outside of St. Augustine?
Yes. We serve all of St. Johns, Clay and Duval counties, including Jacksonville, Ponte Vedra Beach, Green Cove Springs and Flagler Beach.
Are you licensed and insured?
Yes. We are a fully licensed Florida Certified Air Conditioning Contractor (CAC-1824035) and carry all necessary liability insurance.
Heat still not working? Let’s get it fixed.
If you have run through the thermostat, breaker, filter and emergency heat checks and your heater is still not working, give Wright Brothers a call or book online. We will get your home warm again.
Need it fixed? See our heating repair service in St. Augustine.

Leave a Reply